Tech Support > Computers & Technology > XP Upgrade or New Install?
XP Upgrade or New Install?
Posted by Hiker on May 25th, 2004


I currently am running Win 98 (2nd edition) on Athlon 700 mhz. with 256 RAM.
I have a small business (emphasis on SMALL) so reinstalling all software is
time consuming and could also be problematic.

Could I get some pros and cons. I've heard that XP Upgrade often causes
problems. Can anyone give me specifics? I will do the new install if it is
really the best option, but if Upgrade works or can work with some tweaking,
I think it is my preference.


Posted by philo on May 25th, 2004



"Hiker" <nospam@hiker.com> wrote in message
news:6MGsc.3596$dn1.1577@fe2.columbus.rr.com...
although upgrades can certainly work...
there is nothing better than a clean install...

reinstalling your apps may prove to be a lot faster and eaiser
then hours of troubleshooting



Posted by Ron Martell on May 25th, 2004


"Hiker" <nospam@hiker.com> wrote:

XP Upgrades can and do work very well. In fact, I will match the
performance of my Windows XP system, which started at Windows 3.11 and
has been upgraded (and moved to new hardware) over the years to
Windows 95, Windows 95B, Windows 98, Windows 98 SE, Windows Me,
Windows XP Home, and now Windows XP Pro, against a clean install in
terms of both stability and performance. It boots in less than a
minute (1.7 ghz Celeron with 512 mb RAM)

During the beta testing of Windows XP I tried both clean installs and
upgrade installs of the same version on several different occasions.
The only substantive difference that I ever found between an upgrade
install and a clean install was that a clean install was a real
p.i.t.a. because of the additional time that it took to get all of the
applications installed, updated, and configured.

And with Windows XP Microsoft has changed the way that the upgrade
process works. What actually happens when you install Windows XP as
an upgrade is that it:
- renames the existing Windows folder.
- creates a new Windows folder and does a "clean install" of Windows
- imports registry information and needed files and subfolders from
the old Windows folder into the new one.
- deletes the old Windows folder.

So a lot of the excess baggage (old files etc) are dispensed with by
this upgrade procedure.


Having said all this, it is true that not all upgrade installs go
smoothly, but the majority of them do. And if theupgrade does prove
problematic then you still have the option of doing a clean install.


But I am confident that you will find that an upgrade from Windows 98
SE to Windows XP, if properly planned and prepared for, will go well.
See former MVP Gary Woodruff's article on upgrading to XP at
http://aumha.org/win5/a/xpupgrad.htm for some detailed information and
advice on this.

Good luck


Ron Martell Duncan B.C. Canada
--
Microsoft MVP
On-Line Help Computer Service
http://onlinehelp.bc.ca

"The reason computer chips are so small is computers don't eat much."

Posted by Toolman Tim on May 26th, 2004



"Hiker" <nospam@hiker.com> wrote in message
news:6MGsc.3596$dn1.1577@fe2.columbus.rr.com...
Never upgrade the OS - always backup, test backup, backup again, test again,
then do a clean install.




Similar Posts