Does anyone have any comments about this option on the nc8000 (see
http://h18004.www1.hp.com/products/s..._security.html for info
on the option)? Does it slow down the system at all? Could it potentially
cause compatibility headaches with future versions of Windows or Linux?
Could it cause problems with wired or wireless networks? I don't really
think of myself having anything top-secret, and I don't have any
externally-dictated need for it (I am just a college student), but for $25,
maybe it is a worthwhile add-on, but I don't want to add potential
headaches. What do you think? Could you please let me know any other pros
or cons for me?

Thanks,
Karl

Could it potentially

Hi Karl

The main thing here is that even if you purchase this option, you have
to deliberately enable its features if you want it to do anything. As
such, you can buy it, leave it off, and it will be exactly as if you
didn't have it. Therefore, it will not cause headaches with any program
or network because you can always turn it off if it doesn't work.

The main question is: what is the advantage in having it. IMHO, no
advantage in your situation. The security chip will only work with very
limited software, and there is unlikely to be anything that you will use
that would ever need it. There are plenty of software solutions for
encryption if you ever need it.

Notice too the language at the web address: "Can help to reduce
hacking", "Can strengthen wireless user authentication" - pretty weak
claims really.

I have an 'integrated security subsystem' myself (on an IBM, but
basically identical task), and see no point in having it. It came with
my computer, but I would happily remove that feature to save $25!

Hope this helps.

Regards,
Peter