- Blind Subnet
- Posted by C. A. La Varre on August 3rd, 2003
My (Windows) subnet can ping the router and vv but can't see the Internet.
The router sees the Internet just fine.
Does Comcast require being able to broadcast messages to the usersusing UDP
before allowing connection?
I've got the account up and running on a Linux box connected to the cable
modem to Comcast. I have a Windows box connected to the Linux box, using a
192.168.1.0 subnet. I can ping my Window box from Linux and vice versa, I
can ping the Linux outgoing ethernet card (24.131.186.252)o from Windows,
but cannot connect from Windows to the Internet.
My firewall is not blocking the subnet - at least there are no log entries.
But it does block incoming and outgoing broadcast messages
(255.255.255.255). In particular it is blocking broadcasts from
10.222.160.1 and TCP messages from Comcast's 24.131.186.253 to my Comcast
interface card 24.131.186.252.
Would that explain why I can't connect from the Windows box? Any clues on
how to fix it? My firewall GUI doesn't address either of these...
TIA, Andy
- Posted by David H. Lipman on August 3rd, 2003
Get a DSL/Cable router. You have overly convoluted your SOHO LAN. As always, I suggest the
Linksys BEFSR41.
Dave
"C. A. La Varre" <alavarre@123nospam987.amail.lavarre.org> wrote in message
news:5IfXa.41370$cF.15150@rwcrnsc53...
| My (Windows) subnet can ping the router and vv but can't see the Internet.
| The router sees the Internet just fine.
|
| Does Comcast require being able to broadcast messages to the usersusing UDP
| before allowing connection?
|
| I've got the account up and running on a Linux box connected to the cable
| modem to Comcast. I have a Windows box connected to the Linux box, using a
| 192.168.1.0 subnet. I can ping my Window box from Linux and vice versa, I
| can ping the Linux outgoing ethernet card (24.131.186.252)o from Windows,
| but cannot connect from Windows to the Internet.
|
| My firewall is not blocking the subnet - at least there are no log entries.
| But it does block incoming and outgoing broadcast messages
| (255.255.255.255). In particular it is blocking broadcasts from
| 10.222.160.1 and TCP messages from Comcast's 24.131.186.253 to my Comcast
| interface card 24.131.186.252.
|
| Would that explain why I can't connect from the Windows box? Any clues on
| how to fix it? My firewall GUI doesn't address either of these...
|
| TIA, Andy
- Posted by C. A. La Varre on August 4th, 2003
Thanks I'd love to.
Problem is, the "Windows box" is a virtual machine running on top of Linux.
So the Linux *has to be the router.
It's Win4Lin.
So, do they need to be able to broadcast for me to connect?
Cheers, Andy
David H. Lipman wrote:
- Posted by PCNet Guy on August 7th, 2003
No Wonder!
- Posted by redhat_devel on August 7th, 2003
PCNet Guy wrote:
using win4Lin or something like that? If so, you may need to use a
virtual interface [mapped to ETHx].
yea, another windows goof-up. lol
--
"Windows: In a world without fences, who needs gates?"
- Posted by C. A. La Varre on August 8th, 2003
redhat_devel wrote:
Thanks. Win4Lin sent me a beta IP masquerading routine. It creates a dummy
ethx which responds to dhcp or static IP, although apparently the
masquerading part doesn't work.
But I solved the problem; got a router and put it between the cable modem
and Linux, set the Linux NIC to dhcp. So we can all ping and dance
together... :-)
Actually, it is rather a cool little box: Netgear 802.11g combination
router, hub, and WiFi access point for about $150... :-)
So we are CONNECTED...
Cheers, Andy